There have been some recent unexpected downfalls of several luxury e-commerce giants, such as Matchesfashion, Net-a-Porter, and Farfetch, which have sparked industry-wide introspection and concern. Farfetch was bought in a $500m takeover by South Korea’s Coupang and cut 30% of their workforce. Matchesfashion went into administration, owing more than £210m. Yoox Net-a-Porter’s parent company Richemont has been looking for a new buyer for the business since a deal to sell a 47.5% stake to rival Farfetch fell apart. These were all considered the pioneers of luxury online retail but a variety of challenges have led to financial instability and declining market influence. This surprising turn of events serves as a critical lesson for the luxury retail industry, highlighting the inherent risks of digital-first strategies and the evolving preferences of affluent consumers. Even multichannel luxury retailers aren’t immune, with French luxury house LVMH recently reporting a 2% fall in revenue for the first quarter of 2024 to £17.7bn.
Replicating The In-store Personal Service
The very nature of luxury shopping, which relies heavily on exclusivity and personal service, was somewhat diluted in the online format. The bespoke service associated with luxury shopping has been difficult to replicate online, leading to a gap between customer expectations and experience. Luxury consumers demand seamless, highly personalised online interactions. Here, many traditional e-commerce platforms have struggled to keep pace, often due to older technological infrastructures and less agile management practices.
A Crowded Market
Competition also intensified not just from other online retailers but also from brands’ own direct-to-consumer channels, including a growing offering of promotions and discounts, which undermined the unique value propositions of these platforms. With most of the luxury eCom brands stocking third-party brands, they didn’t have their own-brand products to lean on which typically drive a higher margin and therefore better profitability for the business.
External Pressures and Consumer Shifts
The world of technology is constantly changing, and to stay on top, brands need to keep up-to-date with the latest trends and innovations. Luxury consumers are increasingly seeking products that are sustainable and ethical. This has led to a rise in the resale market and a preference for boutique experiences over mass-market, even online. There are also wider market changes, with LVHM stating that their recent loss was driven by a slowdown in the Asian market, where sales dropped 6%. The cost of running luxury eCommerce sites also soared just as the brands began cutting back on wholesale and took back control of their online sales, with a slow progress towards profitability.
Technological and Strategic Misalignments
A significant factor in the struggles of Matches Fashion, Net-a-Porter, and Farfetch has been their inability to fully leverage advanced technologies like AI and augmented reality to enhance the online luxury shopping experience. There has also been a weight of logistical complexities and high operational costs. These platforms expanded rapidly, investing heavily in technology and customer acquisition without sufficient emphasis on profitability or sustainable growth. Richemont bought Net-a-Porter in 2010 before merging it with Yoox five years later in a fraught deal that led to the departure of Net-a-Porter founder Natalie Massenet. A troubled technology and logistics overhaul then dragged on for years, costing the business hundreds of millions of euros.
However there might be a small beacon of hope in the form of MyTheresa. The German luxury etailer announced that its third quarter sales in 2024 are expected to increase between 15%-18% year-on-year.
They attribute their growth to being laser focused on their audience segmentation, they are focusing on big spenders rather than aspirational shoppers who are looking for luxury goods with a discount.
They are also turning to digital channels more than ever. 40% of those who earn more than $100k/year are digital enthusiasts – and they demand digital shopping features. And MyTheresa has been listening. It’s clear that the path forward for luxury ecom will require innovation, adaptability, and a bigger focus on exclusivity, personalisation, and impeccable service.
Sign up for our waitlist now at marketing@wecomm.co.uk to unlock unparalleled insights, unforgettable events, and unbeatable networking opportunities.
Keep up to date by following us at Future of Retail X
